Healing outcomes of open versus closed flap procedures for collagen membrane coverage following immediate dental implant placements with simultaneous guided tissue regeneration

To compare the outcomes of open healing to complete closure for collagen membrane coverage for immediate implant placements with simultaneous guided bone regeneration (GBR) in two retrospective cohorts. The subjects included 118 patients who received Bio-Gide® collagen membrane coverage for immediate implant placements and GBR in 20 anterior and 98 posterior teeth. For 58 patients, gingival flaps were released to achieve full coverage of collagen membrane (CC group). For 60 patients, no efforts were made to release the gingival flaps and collagen membrane was left exposed for open healing (OH group). Antibiotics and analgesics were prescribed for 7 days after surgery. The width of crestal open wounds were measured after surgery (W0), and at 1, 2 and 16 weeks (W16). Changes in bone mass were assessed by cone-beam computed tomography after implant placement and again at W16. Gingival and bone tissues over the implant cover screws were harvested and assessed for 16 patients in the OH group at W16. No wound dehiscence occurred in the CC group from W0 to W16. Both the vertical and horizontal bone dimension changes were not significantly different between the OH and CC group. For the OH group, soft tissue was completely healed at W16 when the initial wound widths were ≤6 mm. For those with initial wound widths ≥ 7 mm, the cover screws were exposed in 5/16 patients at W16 but did not affect the final restorations. Tissue staining showed keratinized mucosa and new bone formation above the dental implant in the OH group. Open healing achieved healing outcomes similar to those of complete closure for collagen membrane coverage following immediate implant placements. For immediate implant placement requiring bone grafting and collagen membrane coverage, it is unnecessary to release the gingival flaps or use tissue grafts to achieve full coverage of the crestal wounds. Open healing with exposed membrane could achieve similar outcomes with less pain and swelling.