Study on critical crack length of wet-sieved and fully graded concrete under mode I loading

The critical crack lengths of wet-sieved concrete and fully graded concrete obtained from experimental measurements, numerical simulation and an analytical solution based on linear elastic fracture mechanics were quantitatively compared. Experiments were conducted on wedge-splitting specimens with depths of 200–1500 mm and a maximum aggregate size of 150 mm. Strain gauges and clip gauges were pasted and mounted along the direction of crack growth to measure the critical crack length. Numerical and analytical methods were used to calculate the critical crack length. The average relative error between the analytical calculations and measurements was still 14%, even for a specimen depth of 1500 mm. The effective fracture toughness was calculated by combining the peak load and critical crack length, resulting in an average relative error of 17%. These results indicate that the existing analytical method for determining the critical crack length is inadequate. Consequently, a modified analytical method was adopted, using 95% of the peak load in the post-peak region and the corresponding crack mouth opening displacement, which provided results that agreed well with the experimental data. Furthermore, the effective fracture toughness could be reasonably derived using the critical crack length from the modified analytical method.