Abstract Background Methane (CH 4 ) oxidation driven by soil aerobic methanotrophs demonstrates the capacity of grassland as a CH 4 sink. Methods In this study, we compared the oxidation characteristics of atmospheric‐level and elevated concentration (10%) CH 4 in a typical grassland (steppe) on the Loess Plateau, an alpine meadow (meadow) on the Qinghai‐Tibet Plateau, and an inland arid‐area artificial grassland (pasture) in northwest China and investigated the communities of active methanotrophs and their contribution to CH 4 oxidation using DNA‐based stable‐isotope probing and Illumina Miseq sequencing. Results The results showed that the oxidation of atmospheric CH 4 only occurred in steppe and meadow soils where the USCγ group of methanotrophs was numerically dominant in the methanotroph community. Pasture soils, with their very low relative abundance of USCγ, did not show atmospheric CH 4 oxidation. However, a DNA‐stable isotope probing experiment with 10% CH 4 indicated that conventional CH 4 oxidizers ( Methylocaldum and Methylocystis ) rather than USCγ communities assimilated significant amounts of 13 CH 4 for growth. Conclusions The CH 4 oxidation mechanisms in the three experimental grassland soils varied significantly. The USCγ group may be obligate oligotrophic microorganisms or their growth requires specific unknown conditions.