Vegetation changes in the understory of nitrogen-sensitive temperate forests over the past 70 years

Since the industrial revolution, atmospheric nitrogen deposition has increased strongly and has been shown to alter nitrogen cycles, species composition and diversity in many ecosystems, including forests. At the same time, nitrogen removal from forests through biomass extraction via historical management techniques has decreased considerably. A proven tool to analyze the effects of long-term environmental changes are vegetation resurveys. In this study, we tested whether environmental changes resulting from atmospheric nitrogen deposition and altered forest management are reflected in the vegetation composition of temperate forest understories in six acidophilic and oligo-mesophilic forest types in south-western Germany. We compared historical surveys from 1950 to 1976 with surveys from 2017/18 and examined changes in the vegetation using NMDS ordinations and Ellenberg indicator values. While an increase in the number of nitrophilic species was detected in all forest types, only the acidophytic and oligotrophic Vaccinio-Abietetum and Luzulo-Quercetum forests (dominated by Abies alba (Mill.) and Quercus spec., respectively) exhibited a replacement of oligotrophic species by nitrophilic species, amounting to an overall trend of eutrophication. Despite the uncertainties resulting from different plot locations and the slow dynamics of forests, we demonstrate a significant trend in the understory vegetation composition, which is likely caused by atmospheric N deposition. Differences in the sensitivity of different forest types indicate an influence of geological and climatic site characteristics and historical land use on the effects of environmental changes.