Afforestation reduced the deep profile soil water sustainability on the semiarid Loess Plateau

Insight into the response of deep soil moisture (SM) to land cover change is crucial for the sustainable management of regional water resources and ecosystems. However, the deep soil water budget and resilience after revegetation are not clear. In this study, seven typical land-cover patterns (artificial arbor, shrub, economic tree, pasture, abandon grassland, and natural grassland) were selected in four different study sites on the Loess Plateau of China. From May 2019 to December 2020, SM was monitored daily at ten depths along a 10 m profile in situ to assess the effect of revegetation on the vertical distribution, availability, and sustainability of soil water. The results indicated that the minimum SM moved to the deeper depth in the planted forest, while the maximum SM gradually moved to a shallower and deeper depth after the conversion of cropland to forestland and grassland, respectively. The difference in soil water use strategies under different revegetation types generated the opposite effect on deep SM availability, resilience, and sustainability. Conversion of cropland to grassland realized the deep soil available water (SAW) increment by 53.3% over the entire measurement period. Besides, the grassland promoting the deep soil water resilience (SWR) and soil water storage variation (ΔSWS) enhanced by 41.6% and 708.7% below 2 m depth, respectively. Whereas, compared to cropland, afforestation decreased the SAW, SWR, and ΔSWS by 17.2%, 10.5%, and 570.7% below 2 m depth, respectively. Furthermore, the deep SWR and ΔSWS were basically negative in the forestland, resulting in an unbalanced deep soil water budget within the year. Despite the significant disadvantages of sustaining the availability and water budget of deep soil water in artificial vegetation, constructing a reasonable land cover and vegetation structure could achieve the soil–water environment balance and the sustainable utilization of ecosystem water resources in the semiarid Chinese Loess Plateau (CLP). The findings of this study provide valuable references and guidance for sustainable vegetation conservation and water resource management and provide design and optimization solutions for vegetation restoration in similar areas of arid and semiarid regions around the world.