Redox Properties of Solid Phase Electron Acceptors Affect Anaerobic Microbial Respiration under Oxygen-Limited Conditions in Floodplain Soils

Mountain floodplain soils often show spatiotemporal variations in redox conditions that arise due to changing hydrology and resulting biogeochemistry. Under oxygen-depleted conditions, solid phase terminal electron acceptors (TEAs) can be used in anaerobic respiration. However, it remains unclear to what degree the redox properties of solid phases limit respiration rates and hence organic matter degradation. Here, we assess such limitations in soils collected across a gradient in native redox states from the Slate River floodplain (Colorado, U.S.A.). We incubated soils under anoxic conditions and quantified CO2 production and microbial Fe(III) reduction, the main microbial metabolic pathway, as well as the reactivity of whole-soil solid phase TEAs toward mediated electrochemical reduction. Fe(III) reduction occurred together with CO2 production in native oxic soils, while neither Fe(II) nor CO2 production was observed in native anoxic soils. Initial CO2 production rates increased with increasing TEA redox reactivity toward mediated electrochemical reduction across all soil depths. Low TEA redox reactivity appears to be caused by elevated Fe(II) concentrations rather than crystallinity of Fe(III) phases. Our findings illustrate that the buildup of Fe(II) in systems with long residence times limits the thermodynamic viability of dissimilatory Fe(III) reduction and thereby limits the mineralization of organic carbon.