Isolating the drivers of the species‐area relationship in experimental habitat islands

Abstract Aim Considered one of ecology's laws, the species‐area relationship (SAR) is among the most intensively studied ecological phenomena, yet the mechanisms through which the SAR arises and under what circumstances remain poorly understood. Here, we experimentally test the effects of area alone in the absence of commonly invoked mechanistic drivers of the SAR in both sub‐tidal bay and inter‐tidal marsh habitats. Location Louisiana, U.S.A. Taxon Invertebrate macrofauna. Methods To determine if surface area alone may generate the SAR, we conducted a small‐scale, ephemeral habitat island experiment in a subtidal soft‐bottom bay and in an intertidal soft‐bottom coastal salt marsh. Cellulose sponge habitat islands of varying surface areas, but with constant energy content and habitat diversity, were deployed in each location to isolate the effects of surface area on the SAR in the absence of species‐energy relationships and habitat diversity. Results Area alone, likely through passive sampling, generated significant SARs in both habitats, with the salt marsh producing the strongest relationship, likely due to differential physical structuring between habitats. Communities of low surface area sponges were generally nested within those of high surface area sponges, and dispersal limitation may have increased the importance of nestedness relative to species replacements in structuring communities between habitats. Main Conclusions That area alone, in the absence of covariates such as energy availability and habitat diversity may, significantly impact the species richness of experimental and ephemeral marine benthic habitat island communities. Our methodology may provide a new avenue for SAR research, allowing for the isolation and simultaneous testing of potential drivers through the physical manipulation of ephemeral habitats.