Performance comparison of state-of-the-art high-speed video cameras for scientific applications

Time-resolved visualization of fast processes using high-speed digital video-cameras has been widely used in most fields of scientific research for over a decade. In many applications, high-speed imaging is used not only to record the time history of a phenomenon but also to quantify it, hence requiring dependable equipment. Important aspects of two-dimensional imaging instrumentation used to qualitatively or quantitatively assess fast-moving scenes include sensitivity, linearity, as well as signal-to-noise ratio (SNR). Under certain circumstances, the weaknesses of commercially available high-speed cameras, i.e., sensitivity, linearity, image lag, etc., render the experiment complicated and uncertain. Our study evaluated two advanced CMOS-based, continuous-recording, high-speed cameras available at the moment of writing. Various parameters, potentially important toward accurate time-resolved measurements and photonic quantification, have been measured under controlled conditions on the bench, using scientific instrumentation. Testing procedures to measure sensitivity, linearity, SNR, shutter accuracy, and image lag are proposed and detailed. The results of the tests, comparing the two high-speed cameras under study, are also presented and discussed. Results show that, with careful implementation and understanding of their performance and limitations, these high-speed cameras are reasonable alternatives to scientific CCD cameras, while also delivering time-resolved imaging data.