Egg size variation in the context of polyandry: a case study using long-term field data from snowy plovers

Abstract Gamete size variation between the sexes is central to the concept of sex roles, however, to what extent gamete size variation within the sexes relates to sex role variation remains unclear. Comparative and theoretical studies suggest that, when clutch size is invariable, polyandry is linked to a reduction of egg size, while increased female-female competition for mates favors early breeding when females cannot monopolize multiple males. To understand whether and how breeding phenology, egg size, and mating behavior are related at the individual level, we studied the reproductive histories of 424 snowy plover females observed in the wild over a 15-year period. Egg size, but not polyandry, were highly repeatable for individual females. Consistent with theoretical predictions, we found that polyandrous females were the earliest breeders and that early clutches contained smaller eggs than clutches initiated later. Neither egg size nor mating behavior showed clear signs of an age-related deterioration, on the contrary, prior experience acquired either through age or local recruitment enabled females to nest early. Taken together, these results suggest that gamete size variation is not linked to mating behavior at the individual level, and, consequently, the adaptive potential of such variation appears to be limited. Teaser Text Comparative avian analyses have linked female polyandry and sex-role reversal to the production of smaller eggs: the notion being that smaller eggs allow polyandrous females to lay multiple sequential clutches quickly. Our research, however, has found that the notion is more complex at the individual level. We found that females who started breeding early in the season were more likely to be polyandrous and produce smaller eggs. Experience was also found to give older and locally-raised females a competitive advantage over younger and inexperienced females vying for early breeding opportunities. Despite this, we found limited evidence that egg size reduction gives a competitive advantage in the scramble for mates. Instead, seasonal variations in egg size can likely be attributed to other factors, such as the survival of early-hatching chicks, resource limitations during egg production, and individual differences. We found that senescence had little impact on egg size or mating behavior. Future research should also examine how seasonality, age, and mating behavior impact the reproductive fitness of males, who provide more parental care than females in many sex role reversed systems. By studying these effects in concert, we can gain a deeper understanding of sex roles in natural populations.