Two cathodic electrochemiluminescence (ECL) pathways were firstly resolved at glassy carbon electrodes for alkaline lucigenin system by using the potential-resolved ECL method. The light emitters for the ECL emission were identified as excited N-methylacridone and excited lucigenin molecules according to the in situ UV–visible absorption spectra and the fluorescence spectra. Two mechanistic schemes are proposed: (1) the pathway for the ECL pre-peak at about −0.37 (versus Ag) is due to the electroreduction of lucigenin forming its radical cation at the electrode surface, which then reacts with dissolved oxygen in the solution to yield light emission; (2) the pathway of the major ECL peak at −0.50 V is due to the reaction of lucigenin with the electrogenerated H2O2.