Lung-RADS Category 3 and 4 Nodules on Lung Cancer Screening in Clinical Practice

BACKGROUND. Lung-RADS category 3 and 4 nodules account for most screening-detected lung cancers and are considered actionable nodules with management implications. The cancer frequency among such nodules is estimated in the Lung-RADS recommendations and has been investigated primarily by means of retrospectively assigned Lung-RADS classifications. OBJECTIVE. The purpose of this study was to assess the frequency of cancer among lung nodules assigned Lung-RADS category 3 or 4 at lung cancer screening (LCS) in clinical practice and to evaluate factors that affect the cancer frequency within each category. METHODS. This retrospective study was based on review of clinical radiology reports of 9148 consecutive low-dose CT LCS examinations performed for 4798 patients between June 2014 and January 2021 as part of an established LCS program. Unique nodules assigned Lung-RADS category 3 or 4 (4A, 4B, or 4X) that were clinically categorized as benign or malignant in a multidisciplinary conference that considered histologic analysis and follow-up imaging were selected for further analysis. Benign diagnoses based on stability required at least 12 months of follow-up imaging. Indeterminate nodules were excluded. Cancer frequencies were evaluated. RESULTS. Of the 9148 LCS examinations, 857 (9.4%) were assigned Lung-RADS category 3, and 721 (7.9%) were assigned category 4. The final analysis included 1297 unique nodules in 1139 patients (598 men, 541 women; mean age, 66.0 ± 6.3 years). A total of 1108 of 1297 (85.4%) nodules were deemed benign, and 189 of 1297 (14.6%) were deemed malignant. The frequencies of malignancy of category 3, 4A, 4B, and 4X nodules were 3.9%, 15.5%, 36.3%, and 76.8%. A total of 45 of 46 (97.8%) endobronchial nodules (all category 4A) were deemed benign on the basis of resolution. Cancer frequency was 13.1% for solid, 24.4% for part-solid, and 13.5% for ground-glass nodules. CONCLUSION. In the application of Lung-RADS to LCS clinical practice, the frequency of Lung-RADS category 3 and 4 nodules and the cancer frequency in these categories were higher than the prevalence and cancer risk estimated for category 3 and 4 nodules in the Lung-RADS recommendations and those reported in earlier studies in which category assignments were retrospective. Nearly all endobronchial category 4A nodules were benign. CLINICAL IMPACT. Future Lung-RADS iterations should consider the findings of this study from real-world practice to improve the clinical utility of the system.