Alternate morphological pathways involved in climbing ability in ten Neotropical anuran species

Abstract Convergent evolution has been shown to be a prominent feature of anuran evolutionary history. Studying the morphological pathways involved in the evolution of a convergent character allows us to test whether deterministic or contingent forces drive the evolution of characters. Here, we have assessed the morphological pathways associated with arboreal habits in species of six families of anurans (Hylidae, Eleutherodactylidae, Strabomantidae, Centrolenidae, Bufonidae and Hemiphractidae) through a comparative analysis of 19 phenotypic characters related to climbing ability. All species showed differences in the assessed characters, exhibiting variations in the distribution of their states and different ranges in all limb lengths. These variations implied a wide distribution across the morphospace as defined by a non-metric multidimensional scaling analysis (NMDS), with Rhinella paraguas (Bufonidae) being the most distinctive species, presenting unique characters such as the absence of intercalary elements, adhesive pads, subarticular tubercles and interphalangealis muscles of the hands. Our findings demonstrate that the morphological mechanisms involved in climbing ability of the ten species are different, suggesting distinct morphological pathways. Consequently, we advocate that historical contingency has an essential role in the evolution of arboreal habits among the species studied.