Liquid crystalline elastomers (LCEs) are soft materials which disorder upon heating through the isotropic transition temperature. The order-disorder phase transition of LCEs results in a contraction of up to ∼50% along the aligned axis. Motivated by this distinctive stimuli-response, LCEs are increasingly considered as low-density actuators. Generally, LCEs are composed entirely of covalent bonds. Recently, we have prepared LCEs with intramesogenic supramolecular bonds from dimerized oxybenzoic acid derivatives and documented distinctive thermomechanical response in these supramolecular LCEs. Here, we report a detailed investigation of phase transitions in supramolecular LCEs by systematically varying the composition to affect the strength of the intermolecular interactions in the polymer network. The order-disorder phase transition is shown to be influenced by the conformation and dissociation of supramolecular dimers. Distinctly, this report isolates and details an LCE composition which undergoes an intermediate transition to an incommensurate phase at lower temperatures than the order-disorder transition.