Evaluating disinfection performance of ultraviolet light-emitting diodes against the microalga Tetraselmis sp.: Assay methods, inactivation efficiencies, and action spectrum

Ultraviolet light-emitting diodes (UV-LEDs) are among the most compact devices and safest technologies in water disinfection systems. However, the validation of different assay methods to evaluate the disinfection performance of different wavelengths (265, 280, 285, and 300 nm) of UV-LEDs toward marine microalgae remains poorly characterized. In this study, several detection assays, namely the culture-based most probable number (MPN) assay, membrane integrity-based vital stain (VS) assay, chlorophyll fluorescence assay, and photochemical efficiency assay, were compared to assess the viability of the marine microalga Tetraselmis sp., with results indicating the MPN assay to be the most sensitive. In addition, this study compared the inactivation kinetics, inactivation efficiency, and energy efficiency of Tetraselmis sp. under different UV wavelengths, as assessed by the VS and MPN assays. The fluence-response curves of Tetraselmis sp. varied with assay and wavelength, with Geeraerd's model fitting all fluence-response microalgal inactivation curves. The results showed a non-significant difference in inactivation efficiency among different wavelengths of UV-LEDs (except for 300 nm) when using the VS assay. On the contrary, significant differences among all wavelengths were observed with respect to inactivation efficiency when using the MPN assay. The wavelength of 265 nm exhibited maximum inactivation efficiency, whereas 285 nm achieved optimal energy efficiency. The UV action spectrum of Tetraselmis sp. exhibited the peak at 265 nm, a finding which matched well with the absorbance spectrum of DNA. The observations from this study provide a theoretical basis and technical support for the application of the emerging UV-LED light sources in the algicidal treatment of marine water.