The use of Artificial Intelligence (AI) for predicting supply chain risk has gained popularity. However, proposed approaches are based on the premise that organisations act alone, rather than a collective when predicting risk, despite the interconnected nature of supply chains. This yields a problem: organisations that have inadequate datasets cannot predict risk. While data-sharing has been proposed to evaluate risk, in practice this does not happen due to privacy concerns. We propose a federated learning approach for collective risk prediction without the risk of data exposure. We ask: Can organisations who have inadequate datasets tap into collective knowledge? This raises a second question: Under what circumstances would collective risk prediction be beneficial? We present an empirical case study where buyers predict order delays from their shared suppliers before and after Covid-19. Results show that federated learning can indeed help supply chain members predict risk effectively, especially for buyers with limited datasets. Training data-imbalance, disruptions, and algorithm choice are significant factors in the efficacy of this approach. Interestingly, data-sharing or collective risk prediction is not always the best choice for buyers with disproportionately larger order-books. We thus call for further research on on local and collective learning paradigms in supply chains.