Computational modeling of membrane proteins is critical to understand biochemical systems and to support chemical biology. In this work, we use a dataset of 448 non-redundant membrane protein chains to expose a “rule” that governs membrane protein structure: free cysteine thiols are not found accessible to oxidative compartments such as the extracellular space, but are rather involved in disulphide bridges. Taking as examples the 1018 three-dimensional models produced during the GPCR Dock, 2008, GPCR Dock, 2010, GPCR Dock, 2013 competitions and 390 models for a GPCR target in CASP13, we show that this rule was not accounted for by the modeling community. We thus highlight a new direction for model development that should lead to more accurate membrane protein models, especially in the loop domains.