Comparative Evaluation of Standard RT-PCR Assays and Commercial Real-Time RT-PCR Kits for Detection of Lassa Virus

Lassa virus (LASV) is a causative agent of hemorrhagic fever epidemic in West Africa. In recent years, it has been transmitted several times to North America, Europe, and Asia. Standard reverse transcription (RT)-PCR and real-time RT-PCR are extensively used for early detection of LASV. However, the high nucleotide diversity of LASV strains complicates the development of appropriate diagnostic assays. Here, we analyzed LASV diversity clustered with geographic location and evaluated the specificity and sensitivity of two standard RT-PCR methods (GPC RT-PCR/1994 and 2007) and four commercial real-time RT-PCR kits (namely, Da an, Mabsky, Bioperfectus, and ZJ) to detect six representative LASV lineages using in vitro synthesized RNA templates. The results showed that the GPC RT-PCR/2007 assay had better sensitivity compared to the GPC RT-PCR/1994 assay. The Mabsky and ZJ kits were able to detect all RNA templates of six LASV lineages. Contrastingly, the Bioperfectus and Da an kits failed to detect lineages IV and V/VI. The limit of detection for lineage I with the Da an, Bioperfectus, and ZJ kits were significantly higher than that of the Mabsky kit at an RNA concentration of 1 × 1010 to 1 × 1011 copies/mL. The Bioperfectus and Da an kits detected lineages II and III at an RNA concentration of 1 × 109 copies/mL, higher than that of the other kits. In conclusion, the GPC RT-PCR/2007 assay and the Mabsky kit were suitable assays for the detection of LASV strains based on good analytical sensitivity and specificity. IMPORTANCE Lassa virus (LASV) is a significant human pathogen causing hemorrhagic fever in West Africa. Increased traveling around the world raises the risk of imported cases to other countries. The high nucleotide diversity of LASV strains clustered with geographic location complicates the development of appropriate diagnostic assays. In this study, we showed that the GPC reverse transcription (RT)-PCR/2007 assay and the Mabsky kit are suitable for detecting most LASV strains. Future assays for molecular detection of LASV should be based on specific countries/regions along with new variants.