Elucidating the Trade-off between Membrane Wetting Resistance and Water Vapor Flux in Membrane Distillation

Membrane distillation (MD) has been receiving considerable attention as a promising technology for desalinating industrial wastewaters. While hydrophobic membranes are essential for the process, increasing membrane surface hydrophobicity generally leads to the reduction of water vapor flux. In this study, we investigate the mechanisms responsible for this trade-off relation in MD. We prepared hydrophobic membranes with different degrees of wetting resistance through coating quartz fiber membranes with a series of alkylsilane molecules while preserving the fiber structures. A trade-off between wetting resistance and water vapor flux was observed in direct-contact MD experiments, with the least-wetting-resistant membrane exhibiting twice as high vapor flux as the most wetting-resistant membrane. Electrochemical impedance analysis, combined with fluorescence microscopy, elucidated that a lower wetting resistance (still water-repelling) allows deeper penetration of the liquid-air interfaces into the membrane, resulting in an increased interfacial area and therefore a larger evaporative vapor flux. Finally, we performed osmotic distillation experiments employing anodized alumina membranes that possess straight nanopores with different degrees of wetting resistance, observed no trade-off, and substantiated this proposed mechanism. Our study provides a guideline to tailor the membrane surface wettability to ensure stable MD operations while maximizing the water recovery rate.