The rotator cuff tear effects on glenohumeral joint tissues, such as superior labrum anterior-posterior (SLAP) lesions, have been studied experimentally or numerically in various cases. In relation to these studies, and as a novel feature of our study, infraspinatus (INF) muscle tear effects on other muscle force variations and stress and strain increases on glenoid labrum (GL), glenoid cartilage (GC) tissues, and a SLAP pathology were investigated. The ITK-SNAP Software (ISS) was used to segment the humerus and glenoid bone. The surface entities were segmented and exported to SolidWorks 2019, where the finite element model (FEM) was completed. Static optimizations of the muscle forces were calculated using a generic model in OpenSim 4.1 for the 0-3.88 s time interval to perform our finite element analyses (FEAs) in ANSYS 19.3 for the intact, partial torn, and fully torn INF muscle. The FEAs were also conducted for the specified time interval. The stress and strain increases on the GL, and GC tissues were determined to be critical when compared with yield strengths. In the case of fully torn INF, the GL and cartilage interfacial principal stress was calculated to be 3.3856 MPa. In the case of the fully torn INF, the principal stress that occurred on the GC tissue was calculated to be 42.465 MPa. In the case of the intact INF, the principal stress that occurred on the labrum was obtained as 4.257 MPa. These results showed that there was no detachment or disorder on the designated tissues caused by the INF muscle tear when the shoulder functioned at 60° of external rotation at 11° of abduction. Nonetheless, a minor amount of external force could cause severe pathological effects on the specified tissues.