Comment on ‘The advanced tokamak path to a compact net electric fusion pilot plant’

Abstract This comment (letter) examines a recent GA concept which they hope will lead to a tokamak fusion pilot plant. As tokamaks are now the closest configuration to practical magnetic fusion, if they cannot do a pilot plant, almost certainly no other device can either. The conclusion is that constructing a tokamak fusion pilot plant at this time is enormously risky, and is almost certainly tremendous waste of scarce fusion resources, which could be better used on other efforts in the fusion effort.