Calix[4]arene-Functionalized Titanium-Oxo Compounds for Perceiving Differences in Catalytic Reactivity Between Mono- and Multimetallic Sites

While the difference in catalytic reactivity between mono- and multimetallic sites is often attributed to more than just the number of active sites, still few catalyst model systems have been developed to explore more underlying causal factors. In this work, we have elaborately designed and constructed three stable calix[4]arene (C4A)-functionalized titanium-oxo compounds, Ti-C4A, Ti4-C4A, and Ti16-C4A, with well-defined crystal structures, increasing nuclearity, and tunable light absorption capacity and energy levels. Among them, Ti-C4A and Ti16-C4A can be taken as model catalysts to compare the differences in reactivity between mono- and multimetallic sites. Taking CO2 photoreduction as the basic catalytic reaction, both compounds can achieve CO2-to-HCOO- conversion with high selectivity (close to 100%). Moreover, the catalytic activity of multimetallic Ti16-C4A is up to 2265.5 μmol g-1 h-1, which is at least 12 times higher than that of monometallic Ti-C4A (180.0 μmol g-1 h-1), and is the best-performing crystalline cluster-based photocatalyst known to date. Catalytic characterization combined with density functional theory calculations shows that in addition to the advantage of having more metal active sites (for adsorption and activation of more CO2 molecules), Ti16-C4A can effectively reduce the activation energy required for the CO2 reduction reaction by completing the multiple electron-proton transfer process rapidly with synergistic metal-ligand catalysis, thus exhibiting superior catalytic performance to that of monometallic Ti-C4A. This work provides a crystalline catalyst model system to explore the potential factors underlying the difference in catalytic reactivity between mono- and multimetallic sites.