Is Native Mass Spectrometry in Ammonium Acetate Really Native? Protein Stability Differences in Biochemically Relevant Salt Solutions

Ammonium acetate is widely used in native mass spectrometry to provide adequate ionic strength without adducting to protein ions, but different ions can preferentially stabilize or destabilize the native form of proteins in solution. The stability of bovine serum albumin (BSA) was investigated in 50 mM solutions of a variety of salts using electrospray emitters with submicron tips to desalt protein ions. The charge-state distribution of BSA is narrow (+14 to +18) in ammonium acetate (AmmAc), whereas it is much broader (+13 to +42) in solutions containing sodium acetate (NaAc), ammonium chloride (AmmCl), potassium chloride (KCl), and sodium chloride (NaCl). The average charge state and percent of unfolded protein increase in these respective solutions, indicating greater extents of protein destabilization and conformational changes. In contrast, no high charge states of either bovine carbonic anhydrase II or IgG1 were formed in AmmAc or NaCl despite their similar melting temperatures to BSA, indicating that the presence of unfolded BSA in some of these solutions is not an artifact of the electrospray ionization process. The charge states formed from the nonvolatile salt solutions do not change significantly for up to 7 min of electrospray, but higher charging occurs after 10 min, consistent with solution acidification. Formation of unfolded BSA in NaAc but not in AmmAc indicates that the cation identity, not acidification, is responsible for structural differences in these two solutions. Temperature-dependent measurements show both increased charging and aggregation at lower temperatures in NaCl:Tris than in AmmAc, consistent with lower protein stability in the former solution. These results are consistent with the order of these ions in the Hofmeister series and indicate that data on protein stability in AmmAc may not be representative of solutions containing nonvolatile salts that are directly relevant to biology.