Plate tectonics through Earth’s history: constraints from the thermal evolution of Earth’s upper mantle

Temporal changes in Earth's tectonic style play a crucial role in understanding the planet's evolution. Modern-style tectonics is characterized by the formation of basaltic crust at divergent plate boundaries and its subsequent recycling at subduction zones, accompanied by wedge mantle formation and arc magmatism. It is commonly believed that the secular cooling of the mantle modified the tectonic style from stagnant lid or heat pipe on an early hotter Earth to horizontal tectonics during Meso-Neoarchean. However, various field, petrographic, and geochemical studies suggest that the onset of plate tectonics ranges from Hadean to Neoproterozoic. In this study, we re-evaluate the primary magma temperature (mantle potential temperature, Tp) of the upper ambient mantle, spanning from Eoarchean to Neoproterozoic. We used basalts from several Archean and Proterozoic greenstone belts worldwide, along with Proterozoic ophiolites, to (re)calculate the Tp using the FRACTIONATE-PT method. We observed a Tp range of 1444–1639°C during the Archean and 1414–1611°C during the Proterozoic. These findings indicate a strong correlation with previously estimated Tp values obtained from PRIMELT3 method. This further highlights strong internal consistency among different methods and supports models of a hot ambient mantle during the Archean and Proterozoic. We further reviewed numerical models regarding the effect of mantle temperature on the viability of early Earth plate tectonics. Such model results, composition of Archean continental crust, recent crustal growth models, and field evidence are consistent with the operation of plate tectonics on an early hotter Earth. The transition from a hotter mantle to a colder one from Eo-Neoarchean resulted in thinner oceanic lithosphere and a less depleted lithospheric mantle. Subduction of this thinner oceanic lithosphere led to modern-style tectonics. The intensity and style of plate tectonics on the early Earth differed from modern tectonics, which emerged during the Neoarchean.