Emerging evidence has revealed a direct differentiation route from hematopoietic stem cells to megakaryocytes (direct route), in addition to the classical differentiation route through a series of restricted hematopoietic progenitors (stepwise route). This raises the question of the importance of two alternative routes for megakaryopoiesis. Here, we developed fate-mapping systems to distinguish the two routes, comparing their quantitative and functional outputs. We found that megakaryocytes were produced through the two routes with comparable kinetics and quantity under homeostasis. Single-cell RNA sequencing of the fate-mapped megakaryocytes revealed that the direct and stepwise routes contributed to the niche-supporting and immune megakaryocytes, respectively, but contributed to the platelet-producing megakaryocytes together. Megakaryocytes derived from the two routes displayed different activities and were differentially regulated by chemotherapy and inflammation. Our work links differentiation route to the heterogeneity of megakaryocytes. Alternative differentiation routes result in variable combinations of functionally distinct megakaryocyte subpopulations poised for different physiological demands.