Rate of benign nodule resection in a lung cancer screening program

Screening with low dose computed tomography (CT) can reduce lung cancer related death at the expense of unavoidable false positive results. The purpose of this study is to measure the rate of surgery for benign nodules, and evaluate characteristics of those nodules.In this study, we evaluated patients in the Lung Cancer Screening (LCS) program across a large tertiary healthcare network from 5/2015 through 10/2021 who underwent surgical resection for a lung nodule. We reviewed the pathology reports and subsequent follow-up to establish whether the nodule was benign or malignant. Imaging characteristics of the nodules were evaluated by a radiology fellow, and we recorded Lung-RADS category, nodule status (baseline, stable, new, growing), FDG uptake on PET/CT, and calculated the risk from the Brock model.During this time period, a total of 21,366 LCS CT was performed in 9050 patients, and 260 patients underwent a following surgical resection. Review of the pathology results revealed: 220 lung cancer (85%), 2 other malignancies (1%), and 38 benign findings (15%). Pathology of the benign nodules was as follows: 12 with scarring/fibrosis, 5 with benign neoplasms, 14 with infection/inflammation, and 7 with other diagnoses. Lung-RADS category was as follows: 4 (11%) Lung-RADS 2, 2 (5%) Lung-Rad 3, 11 (29%) Lung-RADS 4A, 13 (34%) Lung-RADS 4B, and 8 (21%) Lung-RADS 4X. The size of the nodules ranged from 4 to 41 mm with a median of 13 mm. 2 (5%) were ground glass, 10 (26%) were part-solid, and 26 (68%) were solid. FDG-PET/CT was performed in 19 out of 38 cases, of which: 2 (11%) had no uptake, 10 (53%) had mild uptake, 3 (16%) had moderate uptake, and 4 (21%) had intense uptake. Risk assessment by Brock calculator revealed that 9 (24) had <5% (very low) risk; 27 (71%) had 5-65% (low-intermediate) risk, and 2 (5%) had >65% (high) risk.Surgical resection of benign nodules is unavoidable despite application of Lung-RADS guidelines in a modern screening program, with approximately 15% of surgeries being done for benign lesions.