Higher microbial C use efficiency in paddy than in adjacent upland soils: evidence from continental scale

Regularly flooded rice paddies usually show greater soil organic C and microbial-derived C contents than adjacent upland counterparts, but the soil microbial physiological traits under these two different land uses spanning regions remain unclear. Here, we collected 40 pairs of adjacent paddy and upland soils from four different climates (mid temperate, warm temperate, subtropics, and tropics) across eastern China to determine the microbial growth, respiration, and C use efficiency using the 18O-H2O incubation method. Upland soils from warmer climates exhibited lower microbial growth but higher respiration normalized to microbial biomass C (qGrowth and qRespiration, respectively) than those from cooler climates, since the lower soil pH and higher clay content in warmer climates induced a shift from microbial growth to respiration. Whereas, paddy soils from warmer climates had consistently lower qGrowth and qRespiration than cooler climates, probably due to the long term water-logged condition decreased the sensitivity of microbial metabolism in response to lower pH. Paddy soils had higher qGrowth, but lower qRespiration than upland soils, resulting in a greater C use efficiency regardless of climate zones. The difference in microbial C use efficiency between paddy and upland soils was positively correlated to their difference in soil organic C content. From the perspective of microbial C metabolism, the greater organic C accumulation in paddy than that in upland soils is attributed to the weaker microbial uptake of organic C and stronger microbial anabolism under the water-logged condition.