Fundamental bounds on the operation of Fano nonlinear isolators

Nonlinear isolators have attracted significant attention for their ability to break reciprocity and provide isolation without the need of an external bias. A popular approach for the design of such devices is based on Fano resonators, which, due to their sharp frequency response, can lead to very large isolation for moderate input intensities. Here, we show that, independent of their specific implementation, these devices are subject to fundamental bounds on the transmission coefficient in the forward direction versus their quality factor, input power, and nonreciprocal intensity range. Our analysis quantifies a general tradeoff between forward transmission and these metrics, stemming directly from time-reversal symmetry, and that unitary transmission is only possible for vanishing nonreciprocity. Our results also shed light on the operation of resonant nonlinear isolators, reveal their fundamental limitations, and provide indications on how it is possible to design nonlinear isolators with optimal performance.