Purpose: We tested the hypothesis that an exaggerated exercise systolic blood pressure (ESBP) would be associated with the risk of stroke in men with and without a history of cardiovascular disease (CVD). Methods: An ESBP was defined as a maximal systolic blood pressure (SBP) ≥ 210 mmHg during graded exercise testing on a stationary bike until volitional fatigue in 2410 men aged 42 to 61 yr at baseline. Results: Over a median 27-yr follow-up, 419 incident stroke events occurred. In a multivariable adjusted model, men with an ESBP had a significantly increased risk of stroke in the entire cohort (HR = 1.41: 95% CI, 1.15-1.74). This association was still significant following further adjustment for resting SBP (HR = 1.25: 95% CI, 1.01-1.56). In subgroup analysis, ESBP was modestly associated with an increased risk of stroke in men with a history of CVD (HR = 1.37: 95% CI, 0.98-1.93), with no strong evidence of an association in men without a history of CVD (HR = 1.20: 95% CI, 0.90-1.60). Conclusions: These findings suggest that the heightened risk of stroke related to ESBP response in a general population-based sample of men may be primarily driven by a history of CVD. The results underscore the importance of considering exercise blood pressure response when interpreting stress tests, particularly in individuals with pre-existing CVD.