Exchange Coupling Determines Metal-Dependent Efficiency for Iron- and Cobalt-Catalyzed Photochemical CO2 Reduction

Catalysts promoting multielectron charge delocalization offer selectivity for the CO2 reduction reaction (CO2RR) over the competing hydrogen evolution reaction. Here, we show metal–ligand exchange coupling as an example of charge delocalization that can determine the efficiency for photocatalytic CO2RR. A comparative evaluation of iron and cobalt complexes supported by the redox-active ligand tpyPY2Me establishes that the two-electron reduction of [Co(tpyPY2Me)]2+ ([Co]2+) occurs at potentials 770 mV more negative than the [Fe(tpyPY2Me)]2+ ([Fe]2+) analogue by maximizing the exchange coupling in the latter compound. The positive shift in the reduction potential promoted by metal–ligand exchange coupling drives [Fe]2+ to be among the most active and selective molecular catalysts for photochemical CO2RR reported to date, maintaining up to 99% CO product selectivity with total turnover numbers (TONs) and initial turnover frequencies exceeding 30,000 and 900 min–1, respectively. In contrast, [Co]2+ shows much lower CO2RR activity, reaching only ca. 600 TON at 83% CO product selectivity under similar conditions accompanied by rapid catalyst decomposition. The spin density plots of the two-electron reduced [Co]0 complex implicate a paramagnetic open-shell doublet ground state compared to the diamagnetic open-shell singlet ground state of reduced [Fe]0, rationalizing the observed negative shift in two-electron reduction potentials from the [M]2+ species and lowered CO2RR efficiency for the cobalt complex relative to its iron congener. This work emphasizes the contributions of multielectron metal–ligand exchange coupling in promoting effective CO2RR and provides a starting point for the broader incorporation of this strategy in catalyst design.