A comparison of collared and collarless femoral components in primary cemented total hip arthroplasty

Between July 1986 and November 1989, 437 consecutive primary cemented total hip arthroplasties were performed using a straight-stemmed titanium alloy femoral component. Collared and collarless versions of this identical stem were randomly chosen by computer allowing a comparison between 213 collared stems (198 patients) and 224 collarless stems (209 patients). Diagnosis, sex, weight, and average age (72.8 years, collared; 72.0 years, collarless) were similar. Follow-up averaged 76 months (collared) and 72 months (collarless) with 49 patients followed for at least 10 years. Calcar-collar contact was noted in 205 hips (96%) on the initial postoperative radiograph. Early complications, including dislocations (5% each group), were similar. Late complications included 3 deep infections (2 collared, 1 collarless) and 2 postoperative femur fractures (1 each). Hip scores at the most recent follow-up averaged 91.2 and 90.1 in the collared and collarless groups. No or slight pain was noted in 93% of collared and 91.5% of collarless hips. Although no radiographic differences were noted in distal cortical hypertrophy, stem subsidence, and osteolysis, collarless hips lost significantly more medial femoral neck cortical bone (average 0.90 mm vs 0.63 mm). A higher incidence of radiolucent lines in femoral zone VI (20.7% vs 9.4%) was also noted in collarless hips.