Impact of Surfactants on Cumulative Trypsin Activity in Bottom-Up Proteome Analysis

Trypsin digestion plays a pivotal role in successful bottom-up peptide characterization and quantitation. While denaturants are often incorporated to enhance protein solubility, surfactants are recognized to inhibit enzyme activity. However, several reports have suggested that incorporating surfactants or other solvent additives may enhance digestion and MS detection. Here, we assess the impacts of ionic surfactants on cumulative trypsin activity and subsequently evaluate the total digestion efficiency of a proteome mixture by quantitative MS. Although low surfactant concentrations, such as 0.01% SDS or 0.2% SDC, significantly enhanced the initial trypsin activity (by 14 or 42%, respectively), time course assays revealed accelerated enzyme deactivation, evident by 10- or 40-fold reductions in trypsin activity half-life at these respective surfactant concentrations. Despite enhanced initial tryptic activity, quantitative MS analysis of a common liver proteome extract, digested with various surfactants (0.01 or 0.1% SDS, 0.5% SDC), consistently revealed decreased peptide counts and signal intensity, indicative of a lower digestion efficiency compared to a nonsurfactant control. Furthermore, including detergents for digestion did not improve the detection of membrane proteins, nor hydrophobic peptides. These results stress the importance of assessing cumulative enzyme activity when optimizing the digestion of a proteome mixture, particularly in the presence of denaturants.