ESM-Effect: An Effective and Efficient Fine-Tuning Framework towards accurate prediction of Mutation's Functional Effect

Predicting functional properties of mutations like the change in enzyme activity remains challenging and is not well captured by traditional pathogenicity prediction. Yet such functional predictions are crucial in areas like targeted cancer therapy where some drugs may only be administered if a mutation causes an increase in enzyme activity. Current approaches either leverage static Protein-Language Model (PLM) embeddings or complex multi-modal features (e.g., static PLM embeddings, structure, and evolutionary data) and either (1) fall short in accuracy or (2) involve complex data processing and pre-training. Standardized datasets and metrics for robust benchmarking would benefit model development but do not yet exist for functional effect prediction. To address these challenges we develop ESM-Effect, an optimized PLM-based functional effect prediction framework through extensive ablation studies. ESM-Effect fine-tunes ESM2 PLM with an inductive bias regression head to achieve state-of-the-art performance. It surpasses the multi-modal state-of-the-art method PreMode, indicating redundancy of structural and evolutionary features, while training 6.7-times faster. In addition, we develop a benchmarking framework with robust test datasets and strategies, and propose a novel metric for prediction accuracy termed relative Bin-Mean Error (rBME): rBME emphasizes prediction accuracy in challenging, non-clustered, and rare gain-of-function regions and correlates more intuitively with model performance than commonly used Spearmans rho. Finally, we demonstrate partial generalization of ESM-Effect to unseen mutational regions within the same protein, illustrating its potential in precision medicine applications. Extending this generalization across different proteins remains a promising direction for future research. ESM-Effect is available at: https://github.com/moritzgls/ESM-Effect.