Scalp ripple rates for rapid epilepsy differentiation and seizure activity assessment: Applicability and influential factors

We aim to determine whether automatically detected ripple rate (ADRR) of 10-min scalp electroencephalography (EEG) during slow-wave sleep can be a useful tool for rapid epilepsy differentiation and seizure activity assessment, and we analyze the clinical factors that may affect the scalp ripple rates.We retrospectively included 336 patients who underwent long-term video-EEG with a sampling rate ≥1000 Hz, and three groups were established based on their final clinical diagnosis (non-epilepsy; non-active epilepsy [epilepsy being seizure-free for at least 1 year]; and active epilepsy [epilepsy with one or more seizures in the past year]). ADRRs between groups were compared and diagnostic thresholds set according to the maximum of Youden index with the receiver-operating characteristic curve.The 336 patients comprised 49 non-epilepsy and 287 epilepsy patients (95 non-active epilepsy and 192 active epilepsy). The median ADRR of the epilepsy group was significantly greater than in the non-epilepsy group, with a diagnostic threshold of 4.25 /min (specificity 89.8%, sensitivity 47.74%, p<.001). Following stratification by age, the area under the curve was greatest in the 0-20 year subgroup, threshold 4.10 /min (specificity 100%, sensitivity 52.47%, p<.001). Regarding distinguishing active epilepsy from non-active epilepsy patients, the area under the curve was also greatest in patients 0-20 years of age, threshold 13.05/min (specificity 98.36%, sensitivity 35.64%, p<.001). Following stratification by epilepsy type, the diagnostic efficiency was best in children with developmental and epileptic encephalopathies/epileptic encephalopathies (DEEs/EEs) (threshold 5.20/min, specificity 100%, sensitivity 100%) and self-limited focal epilepsies (SeLFEs) (threshold 5.45/min, specificity 80%, sensitivity 100%). Multivariate analysis revealed that the influential factors of ADRRs were age, depth of epileptogenic lesion, and seizure frequency.ADRR of scalp EEG can be a rapid and specific method to differentiate epilepsy and evaluate seizure activity. This method is especially suitable for young patients.