Analysis of the Effects of Melanin Depigmentation on Immunohistochemical Staining

Heavily pigmented lesions are difficult to evaluate histologically, as melanin obscures cellular details. Several classic laboratory techniques aim to clear melanin and allow evaluation. Most of them are old and appeared before immunohistochemistry (IHC) use. Many laboratories perform IHC with aminoethylcarbazole instead of diaminobenzidine (DAB) in heavily pigmented lesions, as red-stained is easy to interpret despite pigmentation. Nevertheless, many laboratories lack alternatives to DAB. The aim of this study is to compare 6 different tissue bleaching techniques and evaluate which is the best for immunohistochemical staining with DAB. In the present study we have selected a case with gross pigmentation because of the high grade of melanin deposition. We have performed 6 different bleaching techniques and subsequently performed 2 different IHC stains, frequently used in melanoma: SOX10 (nuclear) and Melan-A (cytoplasmic). Five different pathologists, 2 of them with expertise in dermatopathology, have blindly reviewed and scored the staining quality. Our results indicate a high grade of interobserver concordance in the evaluation of IHC results between pathologists. All the bleaching techniques that included a sulfuric acid led to tissue detachment from the slide. The best method for SOX10 was that based in potassium permanganate, with a high quality of staining (4 over 5), while the best method for Melan-A was the 1 based in peroxide hydrogen (4 over 5). We consider this study can be quite useful for those laboratories lacking aminoethylcarbazole for IHC techniques, allowing the use of DAB for IHC of heavily pigmented lesions.