Fit for Purpose Approach To Evaluate Detection of Amino Acid Substitutions in Shotgun Proteomics

Amino acid substitutions (AASs) alter proteins from their genome-expected sequences. Accumulation of substitutions in proteins underlies numerous diseases and antibiotic mechanisms. Accurate global detection of AASs and their frequencies is crucial for understanding these mechanisms. Shotgun proteomics provides an untargeted method for measuring AASs but introduces biases when extrapolating from the genome to identify AASs. To characterize these biases, we created a "ground-truth" approach using the similarities betweenEscherichia coli and Salmonella typhimurium to model the complexity of AAS detection. Shotgun proteomics on mixed lysates generated libraries representing ∼100,000 peptide-spectra and 4161 peptide sequences with a single AAS and defined stoichiometry. Identifying S. typhimurium peptide-spectra with only the E. coli genome resulted in 64.1% correctly identified library peptides. Specific AASs exhibit variable identification efficiencies. There was no inherent bias from the stoichiometry of the substitutions. Short peptides and AASs localized near peptide termini had poor identification efficiency. We identify a new class of "scissor substitutions" that gain or lose protease cleavage sites. Scissor substitutions also had poor identification efficiency. This ground-truth AAS library reveals various sources of bias, which will guide the application of shotgun proteomics to validate AAS hypotheses.