Combined Theoretical and Experimental Investigation of Lewis Acid-Carbonyl Interactions for Metathesis

The coordination of a carbonyl to a Lewis acid represents the first step in a wide range of catalytic transformations. In many reactions it is necessary for the Lewis acid to discriminate between starting material and product, and as a result, how these structures behave in solution must be characterized. Herein, we report the application of computational modeling to calculate properties of the solution interactions of acetone and benzaldehyde with FeCl3. Using these chemical models, we can predict spectral features in the carbonyl region of infrared (IR) spectroscopy. These simulated spectra are then directly compared to experimental spectra generated via titration-IR. We observe good agreement between theory and experiment, in that, between 0 and 1 equiv carbonyl with respect to FeCl3, a pairwise interaction dominates the spectra. When >1 equiv carbonyl is present, our theoretical model predicts two possible structures composed of 4:1 carbonyl to FeCl3, for acetone as well as benzaldehyde. When these predicted spectra are compared with titration-IR data, both structures contribute to the observed solution interactions. These findings suggest that the resting state of FeCl3-catalyzed carbonyl-based reactions employing simple substrates starts as a Lewis pair, but this structure is gradually consumed and becomes a highly ligated, catalytically less active Fe-centered complex as the reaction proceeds. An analytical model is proposed to quantify catalyst inhibition due to equilibrium between 1:1 and 4:1 carbonyl:Fe complexes.