Markers of Pain in 3 Different Murine Models of Posttraumatic Osteoarthritis: A Comparison Using Gait Analysis, Imaging, Histology, and Gene Expression

Background: Animal models play an important role in studying posttraumatic osteoarthritis (PTOA) disease progression. Different models exist, such as destabilization of the medial meniscus (DMM), anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) surgical transection (ACLs), and noninvasive ACL rupture. Purpose: To study the effects of PTOA on nociception in 3 different murine models and to relate these findings to macroscopic and microscopic changes in joint tissues. Study Design: Controlled laboratory study. Methods: A total of 42 male C57BL/6 mice, 12 weeks old, were randomly assigned to 4 groups: intact control (n = 10), DMM (n = 10), ACLs (n = 11), and closed ACL rupture (ACLc; n = 11) groups. Gait analysis was performed on 5 mice from the DMM group and 6 mice from ACLs and ACLc groups at 0, 1, 2, 4, 8, and 12 weeks after injury. At the 12-week time point, all mice underwent radiographs and then either micro–computed tomography imaging followed by histology and immunohistochemistry or gene expression analysis of the dorsal root ganglion and tibialis anterior muscle. Results: The peripheral and central pain markers were expressed at significantly higher levels in the synovium of both ACL injury groups when compared with the DMM group. Muscle atrophy genes were significantly upregulated in the ACL injury groups. Pain-related gait behavior started at 4 weeks for the ACL rupture groups and at 12 weeks for the DMM group. High-resolution radiographic imaging and histology demonstrated divergent changes in bone microstructure between the ACLs and DMM groups, suggesting different mechanical loading environments in these models. Conclusion: The principal finding of this study is the presence of markers of nociception at both the gene and the protein levels, with earlier expression in the ACL injury groups when compared with the DMM group. The second finding of this study is that the noninvasive ACL rupture model demonstrated changes comparable with those of the commonly used surgical ACL transection model, supporting use of this clinically realistic model in future studies of PTOA. Clinical Relevance: Quantitative clinical outcomes (imaging, pain scale, gait changes) related to osteoarthritis severity in an animal study, allowing for better understanding of clinical outcomes of osteoarthritis progression after ACL injuries in humans.