129Xe MRI Ventilation Defects in Asthma: What is the Upper Limit of Normal and Minimal Clinically Important Difference?

The minimal clinically important difference (MCID) and upper limit of normal (ULN) for MRI ventilation defect percent (VDP) were previously reported for hyperpolarized 3He gas MRI. Hyperpolarized 129Xe VDP is more sensitive to airway dysfunction than 3He, therefore the objective of this study was to determine the ULN and MCID for 129Xe MRI VDP in healthy and asthma participants. We retrospectively evaluated healthy and asthma participants who underwent spirometry and 129XeMRI on a single visit; participants with asthma completed the asthma control questionnaire (ACQ-7). The MCID was estimated using distribution- (smallest detectable difference [SDD]) and anchor-based (ACQ-7) methods. Two observers measured VDP (semiautomated k-means-cluster segmentation algorithm) in 10 participants with asthma, five-times each in random order, to determine SDD. The ULN was estimated based on the 95% confidence interval of the relationships between VDP and age. Mean VDP was 1.6 ± 1.2% for healthy (n = 27) and 13.7 ± 12.9% for asthma participants (n = 55). ACQ-7 and VDP were correlated (r = .37, p = .006; VDP = 3.5·ACQ + 4.9). The anchor-based MCID was 1.75% while the mean SDD and distribution-based MCID was 2.25%. VDP was correlated with age for healthy participants (p = .56, p =.003; VDP = .04·Age-.01). The ULN for all healthy participants was 2.0%. By age tertiles, the ULN was 1.3% ages 18–39 years, 2.5% for 40–59 years and 3.8% for 60–79 years. The 129Xe MRI VDP MCID was estimated in participants with asthma; the ULN was estimated in healthy participants across a range of ages, both of which provide a way to interpret VDP measurements in clinical investigations.