Incidental Findings on MRIs for Asymmetric Sensorineural Hearing Loss: A Clinical and Economic Analysis

Background The gold-standard assessment of asymmetric sensorineural hearing loss (ASNHL) is contrast-enhanced MRI. Although rates of identifying a vestibular schwannoma are low (<5%), it is generally accepted as cost-effective. Yet, the impact of incidentalomas is rarely considered. This study aims to characterize the incidence of incidentalomas in the workup of ASNHL and quantify the associated socioeconomic burden. Study Design Retrospective cohort study. Setting Single academic institution in a midsized city in the United States. Methods Radiology records were queried for MRI's ordered for ASNHL between January 2012 and November 2022. Results were characterized as “group 1: normal,” “group 2: abnormal read/normal variant,” “group 3: abnormal—likely cause of ASNHL,” or “group 4: abnormal—follow-up needed.” Subsequent costs of workup for group 4 were estimated using Medicare Physician Fee Schedule for Medicare costs, US Congressional Budgeting Office data for private insurer costs, and USC-Brookings Schaeffer Initiative for Health Policy estimates for uninsured individuals. Results Six hundred patients met the inclusion criteria. Eighteen (3.0%) were categorized in group 3, whereas 40 (6.7%) were categorized in group 4. Of these patients, 7.5% (n = 3) had interventions to manage their incidental findings. Estimated per patient cost for further workup of incidental findings amounted to approximately $744, $1,534, and $2,260 for Medicare, private insurance, and uninsured costs, respectively. Conclusion Incidentalomas occur over twice as often as retrocochlear pathologies responsible for ASNHL. Although the number of patients requiring treatment for incidentaloma is low, the economic impact is not insubstantial and should be considered for both individual patients and health system payers.