The electrocatalyzed ammonia oxidation reaction (AOR) is an ambient temperature and pressure process with potential applications for sustainable energy generation and waste ammonia treatment. In this work, we study the mechanism of ammonia oxidation toward N2, NO2–, and NO3– on the (0001)β-NiOOH surface and compare the computed free energy of reaction intermediates to results previously obtained on (0001) β-Ni(OH)2. NiOOH surfaces with a hydroxide vacancy favored NH2–NH2 coupling and reduced the theoretical onset potential for N2, NO2–, and NO3– formation relative to the β-Ni(OH)2 surface. The surface with an oxygen vacancy favored NH–NH coupling and had lower onset potentials for N2 and NO2– formation relative to the β-Ni(OH)2 surface, while NO3– formation was slightly hindered due to its increased stabilization of the precursor adsorbate, *NO2. In general, the NiOOH surface had lower computed onset potentials compared to the Ni(OH)2 surface due to the destabilization of certain adsorbates which form thermodynamic sinks in the AOR pathway, leading to differences in the potential-determining step for the formation of N2 and NO2–.