EXPRESS: Great Expectations: the Moderating Effects of Supplier Service Model and Market Dynamics on Relational Contract Performance

Under a relational contract the value placed on expected future business must outweigh the short-term temptations to deviate for the buyer-supplier relationship to persist. Operational and relational factors that influence this trade-off have been explored, however there is a considerable lack of research on the moderating effects of supplier and market characteristics. We offer insights on how supplier service models and market dynamics impact suppliers’ decisions to renege on the relational contract. Limited access to transactional and contractual data has restricted previous exploration. We overcome this limitation with a detailed dataset in the for-hire truckload transportation sector. We find that a third-party brokerage service model is better able to overcome operational demand challenges and maintain service due to lower capacity constraints and pooling effects as compared to asset-based providers. Further, when the overall market is capacity constrained, long-term relationships become less of a deterrent for suppliers to reject business. In addition, during tightly constrained markets, suppliers respond with higher rejection rates to short-term demand surges but not to historical demand variability.