DFT analysis of the concerted metalation-deprotonation in earth-abundant 3d-transition-metal mediated C–H activations

Methane activation and functionalization under catalytic conditions remains a challenge that must be addressed to make this abundant alkane, the primary component of natural gas, into a more useful resource. One possible method of methane activation is concerted metalation-deprotonation (CMD), which thus far has been largely limited to precious metals and more reactive substrates. In this DFT study, CMD activation of methane is assessed employing more earth-abundant 3d transition metal complexes to assess the effects of metal, ligands, etc. upon the kinetics and thermodynamics of methane C–H activation via CMD mechanisms. Key findings from this study reveal the strong influence spin states as well as ligand modification have on the activation energy barriers. Moreover, an unexpected observation pertaining to ligand modification was seen where the acetate ligand exhibited higher computed free energy barriers compared to the trifluoroacetate ligand. Although acetate is more basic than trifluoroacetate, the ligand directing effects ultimately had a greater influence on the thermodynamic control of the CMD mechanism being studied here.