The performance evaluation of unassayed biochemistry serum controls

Objective To evaluate the inter-bottle variations, stability in consumption and interchangeability of unassayed biochemistry serum controls. Methods Comparison between unassayed serum controls from a domestic Pretrol® and an international Bio-Rad manufacturer was conducted in department of laboratory, in May 2016, with Roche Cobas 8000, Roche Hitachi 7600 and Siemens 2400 modular analyzer. The inter-bottle variation was determined by monitoring the inter-batch variation of 10 bottles of control samples after eliminating the intra-batch variation from the same bottle. Stability in consumption was determined as the precision after 7 days storage under 2 ℃ to 8 ℃ or 30 days of storage under -20 ℃ since reconstitution. The interchangeability was determined as the precisionbetween the controls from different manufacturers for the same test. Results The inter-bottle imprecision of controls from domestic manufacturer for 13 biochemistry tests (CV concentration 1/CV concentration 2) were potassium (0.26%/0.42%), sodium (0.26%/0.21%), phosphorus (0.00%/0.62%), cholesterol (0.56%/0.54%), total protein (0.52%/0.33%), albumin (0.44%/2.00%), alanine aminotransferase (1.72%/0.57%), γ-glutamylaminotransferase (0.52%/0.62%), aspartate aminotransferase (3.10%/1.09%), lactate dehydrogenase (0.76%/0.91%), alkaline phosphatase (1.13%/0.97%), amylase (0.30%/0.39%) and glucose (0.00%/0.40%). The stability in consumption of the controls from the domestic manufacturer (CV concentration 1/CV concentration 2 under 2 ℃ to 8 ℃storage; CV concentration 1/CV concentration 2 under -20 ℃ storage) were potassium (1.06%/0.36%; 0.74%/0.48%), sodium (0.49%/0.59%; 0.72%/0.65%), phosphorus (0.95%/0.80%; 1.43%/0.84%), cholesterol (1.49%/1.58%; 2.17%/1.80%), total protein (0.84%/0.75%; 1.60%/1.68%), albumin (1.33%/2.28%; 1.94%/2.43%), alanine aminotransferase (1.41%/0.51%; 3.24%/1.60%) γ-glutamylaminotransferase (1.16%/1.16%; 2.85%/2.49%), aspartate aminotransferase (4.37%/2.14%; 2.99%/1.31%), lactate dehydrogenase (2.70%/2.54%; 3.84%/2.97%), alkaline phosphatase (2.63%/1.96%; 2.31%/2.10%), amylase (0.95%/2.19%; 1.58%/1.38%) and glucose (0.60%/0.48%; 1.41%/1.55%). The Inter-bottle variation and stability in consumption of biochemistry test unassayed controls from the domestic manufacturer were compatible for clinical assay according to the CV% specification from the Clinical Biochemistry Test Quality Requirement (WS/T 403-2012). The imprecision of the controls from both the domestic and international manufacturers (CVp concentration 1/CVp concentration2; CVq concentration 1/CVq concentration 2) were potassium (0.52%/0.46%; 2.39%/0.47%), sodium (0.30%/0.17%; 0.81%/0.47%), phosphorus (2.72%/1.11%; 4.57%/2.07%), cholesterol (0.29%/1.38%; 2.94%/1.81%), total protein (0.66%/2.46%; 1.85%/2.54%), alkaline phosphatase (2.67%/4.66%; 3.58%/8.55%), total bilirubin (5.71%/5.09%; 9.55%/7.41%), albumin (1.10%/2.61%; 4.79%/1.93%), alanine aminotransferase (6.42%/1.25%; 5.74%/1.63%), γ-glutamylaminotransferase (2.27%/4.35%; 4.38%/0.74%), aspartate aminotransferase (0.56%/2.84%; 0.91%/2.11%) and lactate dehydrogenase (2.36%/2.47%; 3.10%/1.52%). The interchangeability of serum controls from domestic manufacturer was better than clinical serum samples. Conclusion The unassayed serum biochemistry test controls from domestic manufacturer are suitable for the intra-laboratory quality control and showed a promising compatibility for inter-laboratory quality control usage. Key words: Quality control; Clinical chemistry tests; Diagnostic tests,routine; Clinical laboratory techniques