A novel method for predicting the efficacy of topical drugs on onychomycosis: A comparison of efinaconazole and luliconazole

To be effective against onychomycosis, topically applied drugs have to reach the infection site at an effective concentration to exert antifungal activity against the parasitic form of dermatophytes. We established a novel in vitro method for predicting drug efficacy at the infection site and verified the method by comparing the efficacy of two azole class topical anti-onychomycosis drugs. To predict drug efficacy in the nail plate, a human nail permeability test was conducted and the activities of the free-drugs in the upper, middle, and lowest layers of the nail plate were determined by measuring the growth inhibitory zone. Efinaconazole permeated the nail more efficiently than luliconazole, and the amount of efinaconazole in the middle and lowest layers was higher compared with that of luliconazole. Efinaconazole demonstrated antifungal activities at the concentrations in all of the nail layers, whereas luliconazole was only active at the concentrations in the upper and middle layers. The results could be explained by differences in their affinity for keratin and nail permeability. The established method enables the evaluation of nail permeability and anti-arthrospore activity of free-drugs in the nail plate to predict drug efficacy. This method will be useful for new topical drug development.