Clinical Practice Patterns and Evidence-Based Medicine in Blepharoplasty: A 15-Year Review of Continuous Certification Tracer Data from the American Board of Plastic Surgery

Introduction: The American Board of Plastic Surgery (ABPS) Continuous Certification tracer data on blepharoplasty offers valuable information on national trends in clinical practice. The present study was performed to analyze evolving trends in blepharoplasty and compare practice patterns to Evidence-Based Medicine (EBM) publications within the same timeframe. Methods: Tracer data for blepharoplasty procedures performed by ABPS-certified surgeons between 2005 and 2020 was analyzed. Data between two timeframes, 2005-2014 (early cohort, EC) and 2015-2020 (recent cohort, RC), were compared to identify evolving trends in blepharoplasty over time. Results were then compared to EBM-based publications. Results: Of 3,050 blepharoplasties (1,510 EC; 1,540 RC), 82% were performed in female patients and the average age was 56 years. Blepharoplasty was most frequently performed in an ambulatory setting (56%) compared to in hospital (25%); significantly more cases are being performed in the office (p< 0.001) in the RC compared to the EC. Mean surgical duration has decreased by 13 minutes (p< 0.001), and fewer surgeries are being performed with concomitant procedures (p< 0.001). Fewer surgeons use antibiotics (p< 0.001), and fewer surgeons use DVT prophylaxis in the form of sequential compression devices after anesthesia (p< 0.001). More skin resections were performed for upper blepharoplasties (p=0.016), while fewer cases of lower lid blepharoplasty involved either skin-muscle flaps (p=0.038) or transcutaneous fat removal (p=0.004). Most surgeons did not perform canthal tightening during their blepharoplasty (82%). Conclusions: A review of over 15-years of ABPS blepharoplasty tracer data allows surgeons to compare their practice with national trends and EBM. The tracer data illustrates a shift in technique towards shorter and simpler procedures in the office setting.